The Contentious Role of Food Dyes in Children’s Diets

Explore the debate about the effect synthetic food dyes have on children’s behavior and brain health.

Tim Platt/Shutterstock

Do the bright colors in your child’s snacks pose a hidden danger?

There is an ongoing debate over whether synthetic food dyes disrupt young minds. While the regulatory agencies deliberate, recent studies raise alarms about potential links to hyperactivity, restlessness, and even neurodevelopmental effects.

As parents grapple with this perplexing issue, decoding the science behind the artificial rainbow becomes paramount.

How Food Dyes May Disrupt Young Brains

A significant portion of children experience behavioral improvements after decreasing the amount of synthetic food colorings in their diets, according to older research published in The Journal of Pediatrics. The study linked ingestion of tartrazine, also known as E102 (a synthetic lemon-yellow dye), to sleep disruptions, heightened restlessness, and increased irritability.

Story continues below advertisement

A 2022 scientific review published in Cureus highlighted a potential link between blue food dyes and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), prompting concerns about their widespread use in processed foods.

More specifically, Blue No. 1 food coloring emerged as a significant factor, influencing both hyperactive behavior and neurodevelopment in rats and mice. It can also permeate the blood-brain barrier—a protective layer of cells that acts as a filter, keeping potentially harmful substances out—deepening concerns surrounding its neurological effect. A 2012 study highlighted in the review showed that Blue No. 1 significantly affected neurobehavioral parameters in animal studies.

Processed foods and colorants may have potential inflammatory effects on the brain, Annette Cillié, an occupational therapist specializing in sensory integration, told The Epoch Times. Such inflammation could contribute to heightened neurological disorders, including ADHD, inattentiveness, and restlessness, she said.

Diet is not the sole cause of hyperactivity, but it has the potential to be a significant contributing factor, according to Ms. Cillié.

Story continues below advertisement

Petroleum-based artificial food colorants can have detrimental effects on health, she said, noting that eliminating processed foods and colorings may be a crucial strategy for effectively treating children with neurological challenges.

With extensive experience working with neurodivergent children, Ms. Cillié frequently incorporates dietary interventions as an initial therapy step. Children with neurological conditions such as ADHD, Tourette syndrome, or dyslexia often have unique neurological or gut differences affecting detoxification processes, underscoring the importance of addressing dietary factors influencing their behavior and concentration, she noted.

Processed foods undergo extensive refinement and, as a result, typically lack essential nutrients and fiber. This can lead to increased inflammation, oxidative stress, and disruption to the neurotransmitter balance in the brain. Research suggests that these factors are linked to poorer brain health outcomes, Mary Curristin, a nutritionist and wellness coach from ART Health Solutions, told The Epoch Times.

The exact pathophysiological action of colorants is not well understood. Still, the effects of some colorants include reduced neuroplasticity and neuron growth restriction, Dr. Maricia Coertze, a functional medicine practitioner, told The Epoch Times. This effectively restricts the normal development of the brain, which has long-term effects.

The Authorities’ Verdict

A systematic review of research on neurobehavioral outcomes in children exposed to synthetic food dyes shows that 16 out of 25 studies found a positive association between adverse behavioral outcomes in children and exposure to food dyes.

Story continues below advertisement

The National Health Service, the UK’s health care system, has highlighted research indicating a potential correlation between hyperactivity in children and the consumption of certain artificial food colors. Six specific colors, often found in soft drinks, various sweets, and ice cream, have been linked to hyperactivity: E102 (tartrazine), E104 (quinoline yellow), E110 (sunset yellow FCF), E122 (carmoisine), E124 (ponceau 4R), and E129 (allura red).

Products containing these colors must carry a warning label stating, “May have an adverse effect on activity and attention in children.”

However, this is not the case in the United States.

During a 2011 Food Advisory Committee meeting, the Food and Drug Administration determined that artificial food dyes could not be definitively linked to causing hyperactivity in children without diagnosed behavioral disorders. The agency concluded that more research into neurobehavioral pathways is necessary to understand food sensitivities better.

Story continues below advertisement

Nearly 80 percent of the committee believed that a causal relationship between the consumption of color additives and hyperactivity had not yet been established, but 93 percent voted in favor of conducting additional studies to assess the safety of color additives thoroughly. Despite this, 57 percent voted against implementing additional labeling requirements for foods containing certified food colorants.

What Can We Do?

You can reduce exposure to food dyes by avoiding ultra-processed foods and reading labels carefully, specifically looking out for potentially harmful dyes.

Opt for brands that use natural alternatives to synthetic dyes. For example, Kraft has been using turmeric, annatto, and paprika as a substitute for yellow dye in its macaroni and cheese products since 2016.

While avoiding harmful substances is a great start, focusing on wholesome nutrition could be the key to a brain-healing journey, according to Ms. Curristin. The nutritional choices we make play a pivotal role in optimizing brain function by providing essential nutrients crucial for cognitive processes, neurotransmitter function, and overall brain health. A well-balanced, unprocessed diet rich in whole foods to support brain health is critical.

It is important to incorporate omega-3 fatty acids from sources such as oily fish (including salmon), nuts, and seeds, as well as essential B vitamins—particularly B12 and folate found in animal products and leafy greens, she said. Also, adequate glucose from carbohydrates helps maintain alertness and mental energy, while hydration plays a vital role in influencing brain function.