Brain Scans Within Days of Neck Injury May Predict Chronic Pain

‘The brain makes the decision about whether a movement should be painful or not,’ one of the study authors said. 
MDGRPHCS/Shutterstock
Updated:
0:00
A new study suggests that scientists can predict the development of chronic pain just three days after a whiplash injury—an injury caused by the neck bending forcibly forward and then backward—by analyzing brain activity patterns and anxiety levels.

Whiplash is a neck injury that usually occurs from rear-end car crashes and less commonly occurs from sport injuries, physical violence, and other trauma.

Over 3.3 million adults in the United States currently experience chronic pain as a result of whiplash injuries, making it a significant public health concern.

Story continues below advertisement

“Chronic pain remains a major source of disability and suffering worldwide, carrying large health and societal costs,” the study authors wrote.

Key Brain Regions Show Early Warning Signs

The research, published on Oct. 31 in Nature Mental Health, focuses on communication between two critical brain regions: the hippocampus, which serves as the brain’s memory center, and the cerebral cortex, responsible for long-term memory consolidation.

Increased communication between these regions in the days following injury significantly correlates with chronic pain development, according to the study.

“While the underlying mechanisms of chronic pain are not yet fully understood, the brain’s emotional-learning circuits have been hypothesized to play an important role in the development and persistence of chronic pain,” the researchers wrote.

These “circuits” are focused in the hippocampus, which is “responsible for consolidating new memories into long-lasting ones,” Paulo Branco, assistant professor of anesthesiology and pain medicine at Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine and first author of the study, wrote in a statement.
Story continues below advertisement
The more the hippocampus talked to the cortex, the more likely the person was to develop chronic pain, he stated.

Anxiety Levels Play Crucial Role

The research also identified anxiety as a critical factor.

In the study, patients who experienced higher anxiety levels immediately after their accident showed a greater likelihood of developing chronic pain. “If the memory has high emotional significance, then it makes these patients associate this movement with pain,” Branco said.

This link between heightened brain connectivity and anxiety highlights the complex process involved in how we perceive pain.

“While we commonly think of pain as relating only to an injury, it is the brain that actually makes up the pain experience,” Branco said. “The brain makes the decision about whether a movement should be painful or not.”

Story continues below advertisement
The authors also found no significant link between stress levels and the development of chronic pain.

Shifting Focus from Treatment to Prevention

The researchers argue that understanding the timing of chronic pain could shift the treatment landscape from a focus on cure to one on prevention.

“Now that we know there is this critical time period when this happens, we can focus our treatment efforts at this early stage to prevent chronic pain rather than try to cure it, which is much more difficult,” Apkar Apkarian, director of the Center for Translational Pain Research and corresponding author, said in a statement.

“Since anxiety plays an important role for the brain changes, targeting the anxiety immediately after the injury may be able to halt these changes, possibly through anti-anxiety drugs or other medications.”

The research could open new possibilities for treatments focused on hippocampal activity and connectivity, he noted.

Pain Onset Was Traced Back to Moment of Injury

The large-scale longitudinal study, conducted in collaboration with the Technion-Israel Institute of Technology and McGill University, followed more than 200 whiplash patients from March 2016 to December 2021. Of these participants, 177 underwent magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) within three days of injury.
Story continues below advertisement

This patient population provided researchers with an opportunity to study early brain changes, as they could precisely trace the onset of pain to the time of accident. Researchers monitored participants’ pain levels over 12 months to determine who developed chronic pain and who did not.

The research team plans to further investigate the mechanisms driving hippocampal response to injury, examining various physiological and psychological factors that could influence these changes. Their goal is to develop early interventions that can effectively target dysfunctional responses.

The implications of this research extend beyond individual patient care. Chronic pain poses considerable challenges not only to the individuals affected but also to society at large, and it can lead to increased reliance on opioids, contributing to the national opioid epidemic. The results of this study might inform new preventative strategies to improve quality of life for those living with chronic pain.
George Citroner
George Citroner
Author
George Citroner reports on health and medicine, covering topics that include cancer, infectious diseases, and neurodegenerative conditions. He was awarded the Media Orthopaedic Reporting Excellence (MORE) award in 2020 for a story on osteoporosis risk in men.
Related Topics